How Do Credit Card Points Make Banks Money? The Real Math

How do credit card points make banks money? Federal Reserve data shows rewards cost more than swipe fees earn, and that interest is where the profit is.

Ease Advise credit cards graphic with the headline How Credit Card Points Make Banks Money, about interest, fees and rewards.

How do credit card points make banks money? Mostly, they don’t, at least not directly. US Federal Reserve research found that the fees banks earn when you swipe are roughly cancelled out by what they spend on rewards. The profit comes from somewhere else: about 80% of credit card profitability comes from lending, meaning the interest paid by cardholders who carry a balance. Points are the bait that brings in customers and spending; interest and late fees are where the money is made.

For information only, not financial advice.

The three ways a card issuer earns money

A 2022 Federal Reserve staff note, “Credit Card Profitability”, studied 13 large US banks from January 2014 to December 2021, covering about 80% of credit card balances. It splits card income into three streams:

  • Interest. The charge on balances that are not paid off in full. This is the “credit function” of a card.
  • Interchange. A fee paid by the store’s bank to your card’s bank each time you buy something. Together with annual fees, this is the “transaction function”.
  • Usage fees. Late fees, over-limit fees, foreign exchange fees, cash advance fees and similar charges, which only some accounts ever pay.
Income streamWho mainly pays itShare of card profitability (Fed, 2014–2021 average)
Lending (the credit function)Cardholders who carry a balanceAbout 80%
Late and other usage feesMostly cardholders who carry a balanceAbout 15–16%
Transactions (interchange and annual fees, minus rewards and other costs)Merchants, and through prices, all shoppersSlightly negative, about minus 4%

The remaining few percent comes from smaller items such as balance transfers. The shares move from quarter to quarter, but the ranking does not: lending first, fees second, swipes last.

What happens to the money when you swipe

When you pay by card, the store does not receive the full amount. Kellogg School of Management’s research summary explains the chain: the merchant pays a fee to its own bank, and that bank pays a fee to the card network and an interchange fee to the bank that issued your card. The issuer uses interchange to fund rewards.

According to Kellogg, US merchant fees average about 2.2% of the purchase, and the rates are set by the card networks. Many countries cap these fees; the United States does not cap them for credit cards.

Rewards now cost more than the swipe earns

Here is the surprising part. The Fed note found that by the end of 2021, issuers’ net transaction income before rewards was about 1.3 cents per dollar of purchases, while rewards expense was about 1.5 cents per dollar. In other words, on the transaction side alone, the average rewards dollar was a small loss.

That gap opened over time. The Fed’s measure of rewards expense rose by about 25% between 2015 and 2020. A 2024 Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) report makes the same point: rewards have become more expensive for issuers and now dominate their marketing.

So why do banks keep offering points?

Because rewards change behavior in ways that feed the profitable side of the business. A separate Federal Reserve working paper, “Who Pays For Your Rewards?”, compared cards with and without rewards and found:

  • Reward cards lead people to spend more, and less careful users end up with higher unpaid balances.
  • Banks encourage the use of reward cards by offering lower interest rates than on comparable cards without rewards.
  • Financially sophisticated cardholders come out ahead at the expense of less sophisticated ones, whatever their income.

Put simply, points attract a large pool of customers. Some pay in full every month and collect rewards for free. Others carry a balance, and the interest they pay is worth far more to the bank than the points cost.

Who really pays for your rewards?

Two groups, according to the research.

Cardholders who revolve. The Fed note says accounts that carry a balance from month to month pay the majority of interest charges and usage fees. The working paper estimates that reward cards shift about $15 billion a year between cardholders, from less to more educated, and from poorer to richer areas.

Everyone who shops. Kellogg’s summary of Professor Lulu Wang’s research notes that merchants pass card fees on through prices, whether or not a customer uses a rewards card. That means people who pay with cash or debit help fund credit card rewards they never receive.

Points can lose value before you use them

The CFPB analyzed several hundred complaints about rewards programs and found four recurring problems that left consumers without rewards they expected:

  1. Unexpected conditions attached to promotional offers
  2. Devaluation, where points become worth less
  3. Problems redeeming rewards
  4. Revocation, where earned rewards are taken away

Every point that is never redeemed, or is redeemed for less, lowers the issuer’s rewards bill.

Why rewards differ outside the US

Rewards are tied to how much interchange regulators allow. The US offers a natural experiment: the 2011 Durbin Amendment capped interchange on debit cards, and Kellogg reports that debit card rewards declined dramatically afterwards.

Elsewhere, caps are the norm. In the UK, the Payment Systems Regulator enforces interchange fee caps under the UK Interchange Fee Regulation. In Australia, the Reserve Bank’s March 2026 review conclusions lower the maximum interchange fees on debit and consumer credit cards, with most changes taking effect from 1 October 2026 and a new cap on foreign card payments from 1 April 2027. Where interchange is capped, issuers have less swipe income to hand back, which the debit example suggests is why rewards tend to be thinner.

What to do now

  • Pay the statement balance in full. Interest is where issuers earn most of their profit. Rewards worth a cent or two per dollar cannot offset it. If you already carry a balance, our guide to overcoming credit card debt is a better starting point than a rewards card.
  • Don’t spend more to earn points. The Fed research found reward cards push spending up. Buy what you would have bought anyway.
  • Weigh the annual fee honestly. Add up the rewards you actually redeemed last year, not the headline rate, and compare.
  • Read the conditions on sign-up offers. Unexpected promotional conditions were the first problem on the CFPB’s list. Keep a copy of the offer terms.
  • Redeem regularly. Points can be devalued or revoked, so a large unused balance is a risk rather than a savings account.
  • Watch fees abroad. Foreign exchange fees are part of issuers’ fee income. See whether to pay in local or home currency abroad, and our guide on how to find the best credit card for your spending.

FAQ

Do banks lose money on people who pay in full?

Not necessarily on each customer, but the Fed data shows the transaction side as a whole ran at a small loss, about minus 4% of card profitability on average from 2014 to 2021. Issuers accept this because rewards bring in the wider customer base that generates interest and fee income.

Are rewards cards worth it?

Based on the research, they favor people who pay in full, avoid fees and do not let rewards change how much they spend. For someone who carries a balance, interest costs are likely to outweigh the rewards.

Why are debit card rewards so rare in the US?

Debit interchange has been capped since the 2011 Durbin Amendment. With less fee income per swipe, banks cut debit rewards sharply, according to the research summarized by Kellogg.

Bottom line

Credit card points are a marketing cost, not a profit center. Swipe fees pay for most of them, but the Federal Reserve’s numbers show rewards now cost issuers slightly more than swipes bring in. Banks make their money from interest and late fees, paid mainly by cardholders who carry a balance. If you pay in full, spend normally and redeem your points before they lose value, the system works in your favor. If you don’t, you are likely the one funding it.

Sources